Ive put together the best waterproof and smudge-proof eyeliners so you dont need to make the same mistakes that I made! From budget eyeliners to luxury ones, and black ones to blue ones, weve got eyeliner for everyone! Dorman likes the Westmore Wing Effects Liquid Eyeliner. “ a great sweat-proof option as it dries down and sets into place for all-day wear.” It has a thin felt-tip point for precise application and makes it super easy to line your eyes for that classic wing effect. The key to a nonirritating eyeliner besides a cleaner formula is one that glides on effortlessly like Ilia’s gel liner. The formula is smooth and even, so you don’t have to keep going over the same areas for the coverage and color you want. Opt for this brown shade that’s softer than a matte black but still gives you that coveted smoky look. Baby’s First Pml Look Liquid and gel liners are better for precision looks like the cat eye. Pro tip: plant your elbow on a flat surface and make sure your pinky is resti